In June 2018, writer Victor Fiorillo visited the Old Philadelphia Bar. Before entering, he noticed a sign on the window stating, “If you’re not proud to be an American, do not bother to come in.” Intrigued, Fiorillo decided to go inside.

The bar’s atmosphere was immediately defined by overt patriotism. Shortly after his arrival, a man loudly announced he was a former firefighter and a Mexican, before laughing and clarifying the latter was a joke. He then played Lee Greenwood’s 1984 patriotic anthem, “God Bless the USA,” prompting nearly the entire bar to sing along.

This establishment is a neighborhood fixture, known for affordable drinks and a classic, old-school feel. Management explained the sign is intended to set clear expectations for potential customers, ensuring they are prepared for the strongly patriotic environment within.

The bar further positions itself as “hipster-free,” openly catering to its base of longtime local patrons rather than newer residents. This identity came under scrutiny when a photo of the sign was posted in a local Facebook group.

The posting sparked significant backlash. Some community members criticized the message as exclusionary and unwelcoming, expressing concern that it could alienate minorities or immigrants.

One woman shared that she would avoid the bar because her Indian, bearded boyfriend might not feel welcome, stating the sign made her uncomfortable. This highlighted how the message could be perceived as divisive.

Staff defended the sign, insisting it was being misinterpreted. A bartender argued, “If you’re in this country, you should be proud to be an American.” The sign remains in place, continuing to fuel debate about patriotism, inclusion, and the character of a changing neighborhood.